Tony's Pizza

Nereida Guszkowski 

on Google

a year ago

I always stop at this place on my way to the Indian reservation. It has absolutely one of the best pizzas I've had and I lived in Buffalo all my life. There's always pizza ready by the slice. They have an amazing sweet sauce that they put on their pizza. I have also tried their white pizza which is fantastic. I highly recommend this place which is always busy.. 

Jacob Bumpass 

on Google

3 years ago

My wife was visiting New York from California and stopped in here for dinner. The owner was very accommodating and made her a vegan pizza. She smuggled some home for me and this definitely needs to be on the menu! She said the crust was perfect and the toppings were flavorful and fresh. Definitely recommend trying them out if you are in the area. 

David Summerville 

on Google

3 years ago

Have been a customer of this location through out 2 ownership changes but will not return. The kid that works behind the counter is discussing, this is not my first issue with him. He grabs the slices out of the slice warmer with the spatula, drops the slice on the bottom of the warmer picks that same slice with his hands and puts it in the box. Worst $8 I ever spent. Couldn’t even eat the pizza as there were pieces of charred plastic in it as you can see from the picture. This is literally how he put the pizza on the counte... read more

Jennifer Ingersoll 

on Google

2 years ago

Did not have the pizza down that I ordered over the phone so they said ten minutes for the pizza. I waited. Got the pizza home and just a sloppy mess. I hadn't eaten and was hungry for pizza. Should have gone to NT like I always do for a good pizza. 

Michelle Gendron 

on Google

8 months ago

I am editing my previous review. Figured we would try to order again. It has gotten ALOT WORSE! VERY inconsistent! A single pack, small pizza, 10 wings around 50 dollars should not be like this! The crust other pizza was soooooo thin there was 2 to 3 holes in the crust! We work hard for the money we make and will not order from there again! As you can see in the pictures the crust is so thin that light can be seen through it!