Tony's Pizza

Lizzie Fi 

on Google

6 months ago

Five dollars for this... literally not even half full. And not hot/warm... guess don't order the fries? Also asked for garlic bread last time and the itemized reciept b/c of multiple peoples' orders in one... missing both had to call back... 

Joseph Ciesielski 

on Google

a year ago

This has been my place since childhood! Just returned to Buffalo and still quality! The wings have been incredible to good both times I got them! (20-25 minutes drive back home), pizza has been perfect, and always quick and easy! Looks old and dingy! But this is an old school pickup place! Can’t beat it! 

Patty W 

on Google

3 weeks ago

My husband and I have ordered from Tony's for OVER 50 years when it started on Cleveland Dr. Always consistent and happy with food and service. However, tonight my husband ordered a pizza sub (which for over 50 years was a toasted sub roll with sauce, cheese and pepperoni). My husband had a coupon and the correct/exact cash on hand. The girl behind the counter said, "That will be 13.50 + tax. $13.50??? For a pizza sub?? That, in itself, is ridiculous! When my husband pointed out to the girl behind the counter (using ... read more

David Pettigrew 

on Google

a week ago

Overall started out as a good place but just started going downhill with quality of the food, went in for 2 slices today got back to work and was just a grease and soggy mess cheese fell right off the pizza along with the stream of liquid dripping off the bottom of the box safe to say last time goin here 

Rob M 

on Google

5 months ago

Sign outside says Monday night large pizza $17.75, go to pick up large cheese and pepperoni on Monday night and was charged $24? Questioned it, the worker stated that sign hasn’t been updated in years. And they charge 3% extra if you use a card. Dirty business.. how do charge more than the sign says? I won’t be back