Tony's Pizza

Lizzie Fi 

on Google

5 months ago

Five dollars for this... literally not even half full. And not hot/warm... guess don't order the fries? Also asked for garlic bread last time and the itemized reciept b/c of multiple peoples' orders in one... missing both had to call back... 

Patty W 

on Google

a week ago

My husband and I have ordered from Tony's for OVER 50 years when it started on Cleveland Dr. Always consistent and happy with food and service. However, tonight my husband ordered a pizza sub (which for over 50 years was a toasted sub roll with sauce, cheese and pepperoni). My husband had a coupon and the correct/exact cash on hand. The girl behind the counter said, "That will be 13.50 + tax. $13.50??? For a pizza sub?? That, in itself, is ridiculous! When my husband pointed out to the girl behind the counter (using ... read more

Joseph Ciesielski 

on Google

a year ago

This has been my place since childhood! Just returned to Buffalo and still quality! The wings have been incredible to good both times I got them! (20-25 minutes drive back home), pizza has been perfect, and always quick and easy! Looks old and dingy! But this is an old school pickup place! Can’t beat it! 

Rob M 

on Google

4 months ago

Sign outside says Monday night large pizza $17.75, go to pick up large cheese and pepperoni on Monday night and was charged $24? Questioned it, the worker stated that sign hasn’t been updated in years. And they charge 3% extra if you use a card. Dirty business.. how do charge more than the sign says? I won’t be back 

Patricia Clark 

on Google

3 months ago

Got my 1st pizza here. I have lived in area for over 20 years and gave them a try. For me pizza is about the sauce. The pizza I got had no sauce it was spread so thin that it was tasteless. Can't say I would go back. Was really disappointed.